Flailing Proprietor
Harry High-Stakes
The host of Deadwood’s biggest poker event, Harry has poured everything he owns into tonight’s success and failure is not an option.
Murder at Deadwood Saloon
An Immersive Murder Mystery Party of Gun Slingers and Gamblers
For weeks, people have been pouring into the small western town of Deadwood for the biggest poker tournament this side of the Mississippi. Everyone has made this small western frontier town THE place to be.
As the festivities of the poker tournament conclude, a celebration party is planned at the Deadwood Saloon to award the prize money for the tournament and to celebrate what is hoping to be a very financially successful venture for the saloon.
This immersive murder mystery experience blends cowboys, outlaws and gambling with the good, the bad and the ugly, perfect for thrill-seekers who love character-driven mystery.
🎭 Costumes Encouraged 🗝️ Every Guest Plays a Role 🕵️♀️ Solve the Mystery Together
Your job? Piece together the lies and half-truths before time runs out.
How It Works
How This Murder Mystery Works
-
Arrive & Get Your Role
Check in, receive your character, and get quick help jumping in. (Private parties may receive roles ahead of time.)
-
Kickoff & Objectives
Our host explains how objectives work, how to interact, and how play money/prizes work — then invites everyone to mingle.
-
Mingle, Trade Secrets, Build Motives
Guests circulate, uncover relationships, and negotiate information through real conversation — no scripts required.
-
The Murder & Investigation Begins
At the turning point, the victim “dies,” new info is released, and the room shifts into detective mode.
-
Evidence, Voting, Reveal & Prizes
Official evidence is presented, guests vote on who committed the crime, and the solution is revealed.
Who Will You Be Playing?
In a Baker Street Mystery murder mystery party, there are no actors—you and your guests take on the roles of suspects, sleuths, and secret-keepers. Each person receives a unique character with a backstory, hidden objectives, and relationships to uncover throughout the evening. Whether you’re the psychic leading the séance or the maid with something to hide, everyone plays a vital role in solving the case. Here are a few of the characters in the story.
Restless spouse
Henrietta High-Stakes
Once a fixture of the saloon, Henrietta has grown distant and her absences have not gone unnoticed.
Gambling Jack
A legendary poker player whose winning streak defined the circuit until a shocking loss put his reputation in jeopardy.
Lucky Charm
Anna Belle
Known for standing at Jack’s side during every win, Anna Belle’s presence has always been considered part of his success.
Surprise Winner
Mitch Maverick
A traveling businessman whose unlikely victory has everyone questioning whether skill, or something else, carried him to the top.
Southern Shark
Holly Hickok
Young, restless, and intoxicated by the freedom of the West… and the trouble that comes with it.
Desperate Gambler
Clay Coldwell
Deep in debt and out of time, Clay is betting more than he can afford to lose.
Compromised Lawman
Sheriff Sam
Tasked with keeping order in a town that resists it, Sheriff Sam walks a fine line between justice and survival.
More characters revealed at the event
What Makes Baker Street Mystery Different
🕵️
No Actors. No Scripts. You Are the Mystery.
Unlike traditional murder mystery dinners, there are no performers on stage and no scripted scenes to watch. Every guest receives a character with secrets, objectives, and relationships — and the story unfolds through natural conversation and discovery, not cue cards.
🎭
Everyone Has a Role (No Spectators)
Every guest is involved from start to finish. Whether you’re bold, analytical, or quietly observant, the game adapts to your style.
🧩
Built for Real Conversations, Not Performances
This experience is ideal for people who don’t want to “act.”
No accents. No monologues. No embarrassment. Just guided prompts that make engagement easy and comfortable.
🔎
Clues Are Discovered, Not Handed Out
There are no timed clue drops. Evidence emerges through::
• Private conversations
• Shared discoveries
• Strategic information trading
The mystery rewards curiosity, collaboration, and critical thinking.
What Our Suspects Say
Kelli Winters
"Super fun idea to celebrate a friends birthday! Loved that each person has little tid bits of info. "
Robin Mangum
"Great evening. Had a wonderful time. All of the details were very well curated."
Houston Yarberry
"Sam was awesome! She made the experience very enjoyable."
FAQs
You don’t need acting experience to participate. Guests receive clear character guides, objectives, and host support. Acting in character is optional. Some guests lean into roleplay, while others focus on strategy, deduction, and conversation. The experience works at any comfort level.
Our parties are designed to be intuitive and welcoming—even for first‑timers. Many competitors also offer “interactive” events, but theirs often still feature central actors to manage pace and plot. We trust the group to carry the narrative, supported by materials and structure—not scripts.
For most parties, we need a minimum of 20 participants, but can accommodate up to 100 or more, depending on venue and setup. For smaller groups, we have a selection of micro-themes that can run with as little as 8 guests.
Our mysteries are set up in a way in which roles accommodate different comfort levels. By providing clear objectives we give each guests the flexibility to take a more reserved approach or to fully-embrace their character. Guests receive clear character guides, objectives, and host support.
Characters are provided digitally or in person, depending on the event format.
If chosen, private event attendees can be emailed their characters, backstories, and goals ahead of time. Most public event participants receive assignments onsite.
Themed attire is encouraged and helps immersion but is optional. Themes range from 1920s speakeasy to supernatural seance or winery mystery—costume inspiration guides are provided to help participants prepare. Guests may dress comfortably or lean into the theme for fun.
Since we use licenses to sell tickets, we only provide a fully-hosted experience. This ensures that you receive a high-quality, immersive murder mystery event, complete with all the necessary materials, guidance, and support for a memorable experience.
Upcoming Murder at Deadwood Saloon Events
1 event found.
Private Event – Murder at Deadwood Saloon
It’s the First Annual Deadwood Poker Tournament! For weeks, people have been pouring into the small western town of Deadwood for the biggest poker tournament this side of the Mississippi.… Read More »Private Event – Murder at Deadwood Saloon
This story is appropriately licensed for commercial ticket sales from Night of Mystery .